Halifax Media Co-op

News from Nova Scotia's Grassroots

More independent news:
Do you want free independent news delivered weekly? sign up now
Can you support independent journalists with $5? donate today!

All Charges Dropped for HMC Journalist Miles Howe

Chill remains for on-the-ground journalists

by Hillary Bain Lindsay

Halifax Media Co-op journalist Miles Howe at an anti-fracking rally.  Howe was arrested three times while covering shale gas protests in New Brunswick.  All charges have now been dropped.  Photo: Patty Crow
Halifax Media Co-op journalist Miles Howe at an anti-fracking rally. Howe was arrested three times while covering shale gas protests in New Brunswick. All charges have now been dropped. Photo: Patty Crow

K'JIPUKTUK (Halifax) - On February 27, the day before he was scheduled to appear in court in Moncton, Halifax Media Co-op journalist Miles Howe found out that the charges relating to his November 26 arrest had been dropped.

"It's always a relief," says Howe, who by this time is familiar with the feeling.

Howe has been arrested three times since he began covering anti-shale gas protests in New Brunswick less than a year ago. Each time, the charges were subsequently dropped, but Howe's ability to do his job as a journalist was significantly hindered in the interim.

The pattern raises questions about the RCMP's treatment of journalists that "get in the way," according to Hugo Rodrigues, president of the Canadian Association of Journalists.

"To use tactics that intimidate [journalists], such as arrest and charge, but then not follow through with the charge, or just arrest, or harrass–it becomes a pattern of behaviour," says Rodrigues. "It raises the legitimate question: Is he being targeted by the RCMP?"

In June 2013, Howe travelled to Elsipogtog to cover an emerging resistance to shale gas development in New Brunswick. Howe remained for two months, unable to leave what he felt was a critically important and quickly developing story.

In New Brunswick, Howe found a shale gas industry that was essentially guarded by the RCMP, and a people–at that time protesters were mostly Mi'kmaq–that were resisting by putting their bodies on the line. "There were people being arrested–sometimes in a violent manner–in front of me on a weekly basis and there was no other media to observe what was going on," says Howe.

All told, Howe spent about five months in Elsipogtog, filing stories for the Media Co-op on the RCMP's treatment of protesters, First Nations rights, the shale gas industry's impact on the environment, and the role of government.

Following his first and second arrest, after recovering his equipment and being released from jail, Howe resumed his job as a journalist. That pattern changed after his third arrest, when he was forced to sign conditions in order to be released from jail. Howe's conditions prohibited him from coming within one kilometer of protest sites, SWN’s (the shale gas company) equipment or SWN employees.

"In essence what that meant is it was impossible to do any degree of on the ground reporting," says Howe.

Not only did the conditions prevent Howe from covering the story, "that he's probably covered to a greater extent than many other journalists out there," says Rodrigues, but "we also have to ask how many other journalists were kept away."

Other journalists may not be willing to risk arrest and all that it entails in order to cover a story, says Rodrigues.  "It has a chilling effect."

RCMP have also refused to return Howe's cell phone and camera since his November 26 arrest, saying that they may contain useful information for the RCMP.

In February, a provincial court judge granted a RCMP request to have access to videotape and photographs taken by five media organizations of anti-shale gas protests in New Brunswick in October.

This is a disturbing trend, says Rodrigues.

"When police run around and start seizing our equipment and raw footage, it makes it really difficult for us to be seen as anything but people who are there to help police, and that's not an appropriate way for journalists to be seen in a democratic society," says Rodrigues.  

"We're not members of law enforcement, but if everything we do is subject–at law enforcement's whim–to be part of their investigation, it's really difficult for us as journalists to be able to continue to do our best work."

Want more grassroots coverage?
Join the Media Co-op today.
603 words





This is just a comment to congrulate Miles on his charges being drooped.

Well Done, Miles!

Canada's political police

In her book the End of America, Naomi Wolf discusses the ten stages or steps by which open societies are usually shut down...three of them being that security forces engage in arbitrary detention and release, try to control the press and begin to target key individuals.  All of these have probably been at play in the RCMP going after Miles to protect SWN and their own activities on the corporation's behalf from scrutiny.  As Murray Dobbin discusses in an important article entitled "Big Oil's Chockehold on Canadian Democracy", http://www.counterpunch.org/2014/02/11/big-oils-chokehold-on-canadian-democracy/ this country has indeed entered a sinister new stage under Stephen Harper, where the security apparatus has been effectively "enlisted in the direct and immediate service of the oil industry".  He begins by reminding us of Mussolini's definition of fascism as the merger of state and corporate power.  Here's an excerpt:

Paranoid governments in the past have used the RCMP and CSIS to spy on political enemies, infiltrate activist organizations and have even sent in agent provocateurs to tarnish the image of political protest. But to arrange to have intelligence and police agencies, government representatives, a government agency supposedly responsible to Parliament and the Canadian people (the NEB) and corporate executives all sit around a table to explicitly violate not only our democratic rights but the law of the land is a grotesque step beyond.

The open use of government security forces on behalf of private corporations was first revealed in the Vancouver Observer on Nov. 19 last year. Reporter Matthew Millar wrote:

“On May 23, 2013, Natural Resources Canada hosted a ‘Classified Briefing for Energy & Utilities Sector Stakeholders’ in collaboration with CSIS and the RCMP at CSIS’s headquarters in Ottawa.”

Millar’s FOIs revealed just how casual corporatism has become under the Harper regime. The meeting was announced by way of a one page announcement entitled “Classified briefing for Energy & Utilities Sector Stakeholders — hosted by Natural resources Canada, in collaboration with CSIS and RCMP” and was replete with the logos of some of the corporations being briefed, including Bruce Power and Brookfield Renewable Energy Partners who were co-hosts of a reception at the Chateau Laurier in Ottawa. The breakfast meeting the next morning was sponsored and paid for by Gateway’s Enbridge. The collusion of all these players had been going on for so long (since 2005 according to Millar) that the meeting was billed as any other Natural Resources Canada meeting might be — just business as usual.     

The whole article is well worth a read. 

Anyway, congratulations to Miles for having the charges dropped and for his stellar work in Elsipogtog.  He continues to educate and inspire with his journalism.  When CBC (speaking of "captured" public institutions)  goes out of it's way to discredit him and declare him "not a journalist", he's obviously doing something right.       


The site for the Halifax local of The Media Co-op has been archived and will no longer be updated. Please visit the main Media Co-op website to learn more about the organization.