Halifax Media Co-op

News from Nova Scotia's Grassroots

More independent news:
Do you want free independent news delivered weekly? sign up now
Can you support independent journalists with $5? donate today!

Community Services cuts back on special transportation needs

by Robert Devet

Community Services is becoming (ever more) stingy in providing bus passes to Income Assistance recipients who need transportation support, advocates tell the Halifax Media Co-op. Photo Hfx chris at en.wikipedia
Community Services is becoming (ever more) stingy in providing bus passes to Income Assistance recipients who need transportation support, advocates tell the Halifax Media Co-op. Photo Hfx chris at en.wikipedia

KJIPUKTUK) HALIFAX - Community Services is making a concerted effort to reduce the number of bus passes it provides to Income Assistance recipients.

That's what anti poverty advocates and social workers tell the Halifax Media Co-op.

Evan Coole, who works for Dalhousie Legal Aid, hears about people's bus pass being taken away and new requests being denied all the time.

Often people are told that they need at least twelve medical appointments within a month to qualify for a bus pass, he says.

That's a lot of appointments.

Paul O'Hara, a social worker with the North End Community Health Centre, sees the same thing.

“You have to justify, typically through medical documentation, that you need a bus pass,” he explains. “If you go to your doctor five times a month they will give you money for bus tickets instead.”

It's not a new phenomenon but it seems to happen more frequently lately, these advocates believe.

The Department of Community Services says nothing has changed.

“In HRM clients who require transportation for medical appointments or employment/training-related activities may be provided a bus pass if the travel is frequent enough to merit a bus pass, which costs $78 per month,” Lori Errington, spokesperson for the Department, writes to the Halifax Media Co-op.

“For clients with infrequent appointments, money to purchase bus tickets (or taxi fare) can be the most economical option,” Errington writes.

Yet social justice advocates we talked to argue that what they see happening on the ground reflects a deliberate choice by the department.

A choice that they believe is driven by spending constraints and the overall austerity agenda.

Departmental regulations indeed require that the most economical option be chosen when it comes to supporting transportation needs, these social workers say.

But nowhere does it define what that means in practical terms, nor does it prescribe in concrete terms the type of evidence that must be provided in order to approve a request.

In other words, there is enough wriggle room for the department to be compassionate, if it so chooses.

The process to determine whether a request for a bus pass, or any “special need” for that matter, is justified, is a source of frustration for all social workers and advocates we talked to.

The department often relies on its anonymous internal experts to justify its denials, says Fiona Traynor, who as a Dalhousie Legal Aid worker over the years has appealed many special needs decisions.

Meanwhile, the type of evidence required to justify an approval often is exhaustive, say social workers.

Community Services staff often lack the sophisticated medical expertise to interpret that evidence, they add.

“A woman who called me yesterday, she has diabetes, developed neurological pain, she can't walk to her son's place, she can't walk to her doctor in downtown Halifax,” says Coole.

“Yet they're taking away her bus pass to save money. It's downright cruel,” he says.

“And this is what I don't get about Community Services,” Coole says. “If you cut people off that person's needs go up somewhere else. It solves nothing.”

For O'Hara what is ultimately at stake is inclusion.

“Increasingly we are excluding people who are economically marginal from participating in their community,” he says.

“We won't give them a bus pass so they can't get to church, or the library, or visit family, or engage in any other way with their community.

“Even when it comes to getting your groceries. When you're poor you have to look for bargains and go to different places.”

“More and more the government is resorting to austerity measures on the backs of people who are less able to speak up for themselves,” says O'Hara.

Follow Robert DeVet on Twitter


Want more grassroots coverage?
Join the Media Co-op today.
615 words


Ya! another example of how the ESIA Program abuses their client


I was just reading this artcle and I must say that with the ESIA Program throug the Department of Community Servies, as it has been known for some time they like to abuse thoese ESIA clients who needs to depend on the system in more ways then one. First - it is poeple looseing their special diets - then comes to doctors and other medcial professionals getting phone calls from caseworkers further questioning them on rasons for clients special diet needs - then now this. YA! Department of Cmmunity loves to  make life for it's clients "expecially thoese with disabiles", diffcult. Oh and let not forget the fact that they did not give us an increase in our personial allowences in 2014.

When they loose buspass funding, not only thier income gets lower, however also their right to transportation if serouisially being interfeared with. Ok to put this in perpective - say if an ESIA client who looses their bus pass, and cannot get it back by taking to their casewok - the they appeial it - and it gets denied throug the appeial hearing -   the question then becomes - "howelse are they expected to pay for their buspass or any transportation need for that matter?"  Thoese who are disabled simpailly cannot partispate in the community without a buspass. Also it needs to be understood not all, as a mattere of fact from my pesonial expeence of knowing the communty of people who are on income assitance,formost of them turing to thier families for money to pay for any of their transportation needs, including buspasses is not an option.

The part of ESIA policy which talks about Cverage forTransporaion, bus passes needs change. The other thing is, some people who are on the ESIA system do volenteer work in the community.  These people need transportation to attned their volenteer work. Are the ones who do volenteer work going to loose their bus passes as well in the fut-her?  

In my fanal statement on this comment, if what the ESIA staff of Department of Communty Services are doing keep up, then I think eveniall we are going to see more ESIA cliants panhandling on Spring Garden Rode. Either that or ESIA are going to develop serouis mental health issues because of the way the system is treating them.

 Kendall Woth  


Transportation allowance cut even for those in wheelchairs!

“For clients with infrequent appointments, money to purchase bus tickets (or taxi fare) can be the most economical option,” Errington writes.

It makes my blood boil to read this. Someone needs to enlighten Ms. Errington, and she is now on my list of people I will be writing to shortly to inform them that ESIA does not provide money for taxis, even if you are in a wheelchair, as I am.

After 15 years of receiving a minimum of $60 for taxis, my transportation allowance was slashed to a mere $20.

The site for the Halifax local of The Media Co-op has been archived and will no longer be updated. Please visit the main Media Co-op website to learn more about the organization.